BenefitBeacon

← All tools

HMO vs PPO vs HDHP Comparison

Working

HMO, PPO, and HDHP are the three main kinds of health plan, and they differ in the premium, the network, and how care is paid for. In practice, an HMO has the lowest premium but the smallest network and needs a referral to see a specialist. A PPO has a higher premium but a larger network and no referral. An HDHP has the lowest premium and the highest deductible, and it can be paired with a Health Savings Account. This comparison works out the annual premium of each from the monthly premiums entered, so the premium cost is clear, and it explains the trade-offs.

Illustration of rising bars and a coin, representing hmo vs ppo vs hdhp.

What this calculator does

This comparison answers which plan has the lowest annual premium and what the trade-offs are. You put in the monthly premium of the HMO, the PPO, and the HDHP, and it works out the annual premium of each and flags the cheapest. It also explains the network, the referrals, and the deductible of each kind. For most people, it does not cover the out-of-pocket costs, which depend on the care needed, and it does not choose for you.

How this is calculated

Enter the monthly premium of each plan from the plan documents or the employer’s open enrollment materials. It multiplies each by 12 to give the annual premium and flags the cheapest. Then weigh the trade-offs. Day to day, an HMO has the lowest premium and the smallest network, and it needs a referral to see a specialist. A PPO has a higher premium, a larger network, and no referral. For most people, an HDHP has the lowest premium and the highest deductible, and it can be paired with a Health Savings Account, which lets the money be saved tax-free for medical costs. If a lot of care is needed, the deductible matters more than the premium, so check the deductible and the out-of-pocket maximum too.

Source

Compare the plan types at healthcare.gov — Plan Types. The premiums are on the plan documents or the employer’s open enrollment materials.

Limitations

This comparison covers the premiums only; it doesn't cover the deductible, the copays, or the out-of-pocket maximum, which must be checked on the plan documents. The cheapest premium is not always the cheapest plan overall. What you get is a premium comparison, not a recommendation.

What each input means

HMO monthly premium. The HMO’s monthly premium. PPO monthly premium. The PPO’s monthly premium. HDHP monthly premium. The HDHP’s monthly premium.

How to read your result

It shows the annual premium of each plan and flags the cheapest. Then weigh the trade-offs: the HMO has the smallest network and needs referrals, the PPO has the largest network and no referrals, and the HDHP has the highest deductible but can pair with an HSA.

Worked example

Take a person choosing between three plans: an HMO at $400 a month, a PPO at $550 a month, and an HDHP at $300 a month. The annual premiums are $4,800 for the HMO, $6,600 for the PPO, and $3,600 for the HDHP, so the HDHP has the lowest premium. But the HDHP has the highest deductible, so if a lot of care is needed, the HMO or the PPO may cost less overall. The person should check the deductible and the out-of-pocket maximum of each before deciding.

What to do next

Check the deductible, the copays, and the out-of-pocket maximum of each plan, and whether the doctors are in the network. The bronze vs silver vs gold comparison can compare the metal levels, and the COBRA vs ACA comparison can compare the coverage after a job loss.

When each plan wins

An HMO usually wins when the premium matters most and the person is happy with a smaller network, because the HMO has the lowest premium and the care is coordinated by a primary care doctor, although a referral is needed to see a specialist. A PPO usually wins when the choice of doctors matters most, because the PPO has the largest network and no referral is needed, although the premium is higher. An HDHP usually wins when the person is healthy and wants the lowest premium, because the HDHP has the lowest premium and can pair with a Health Savings Account, which lets the money be saved tax-free for medical costs, although the deductible is high and the person pays most of the care costs until it is met. The cheapest premium isn't always the cheapest plan overall: if a lot of care is needed, the deductible and the out-of-pocket maximum matter more than the premium, so check all three before deciding. Check whether the doctors are in the network, because a doctor outside the network can cost much more, especially on an HMO. Compare the plans during open enrollment, because the premiums and the networks change every year, and the bronze vs silver vs gold comparison on this site can compare the metal levels.

Common questions

What is an HMO?

A plan with the lowest premium, the smallest network, and a referral needed to see a specialist.

What is a PPO?

A plan with a higher premium, a larger network, and no referral needed to see a specialist.

What is an HDHP?

A high-deductible health plan, with the lowest premium and the highest deductible, which can pair with a Health Savings Account.

What is an HSA?

A Health Savings Account, which lets the money be saved tax-free for medical costs, paired with an HDHP.

Is the cheapest premium always best?

No. If a lot of care is needed, the deductible and the out-of-pocket maximum matter more.

Sources

Related guides

Official sources

Benefit rules, amounts and application steps come from the administering agency. These links open the official agency home page in a new tab. Program pages link to the agency named on the page.