Bronze vs Silver vs Gold Comparison
Working
Marketplace plans come in metal levels: bronze, silver, gold, and platinum. In real terms, the metal level shows how the costs are split: a bronze plan has the lowest premium and the highest deductible, and the insurer pays about 60% of the average costs, while a gold plan has the highest premium and the lowest deductible, and the insurer pays about 80%. Silver is in the middle, with the insurer paying about 70%. This comparison works out an estimated annual cost for each level from the premiums, the deductibles, and the expected care, so the trade-off is clear. Take it as an estimate, not a quote, because the coinsurance and the copays are not included.
What this calculator does
This comparison answers which metal level is estimated to cost least for the care expected. In real terms, you put in the monthly premium and the deductible of the bronze, silver, and gold plans, and the expected annual medical costs, and it works out an estimated annual cost for each: the annual premium plus the care costs up to the deductible. It also explains the metal levels and the cost-sharing reductions that only silver plans get. It does not choose for you.
How this is calculated
Enter the monthly premium and the deductible of each plan from healthcare.gov, and the expected annual medical costs, which is the total the care would cost without insurance. It works out the estimated annual cost of each plan as the annual premium plus the smaller of the expected care and the deductible. This is a simplification: it leaves out the coinsurance and the copays after the deductible, so treat it as an estimate, not a quote. Then weigh the trade-offs: bronze has the lowest premium but the highest deductible, so it suits people who need little care; gold has the highest premium but the lowest deductible, so it suits people who need a lot of care; silver is in the middle, and it is the only level that gets cost-sharing reductions, which cut the deductible and the copays for people with low income.
Source
Compare the metal levels at healthcare.gov — Plan Categories. The premiums and deductibles are on healthcare.gov.
Limitations
This comparison is an estimate: it leaves out the coinsurance and the copays after the deductible, and it does not cover the cost-sharing reductions, which only silver plans get. What you get is an estimated comparison, not a quote or a recommendation.
What each input means
Monthly premium and deductible. For each of the bronze, silver, and gold plans, from healthcare.gov. Expected annual medical costs. The total the care would cost without insurance, in dollars per year.
How to read your result
It shows the estimated annual cost of each metal level: the annual premium plus the care costs up to the deductible. Bronze usually wins when little care is needed, and gold usually wins when a lot of care is needed. Silver is the only level that gets cost-sharing reductions.
Worked example
Take a shopper with expected annual medical costs of $3,000. For most people, the bronze plan costs $300 a month with a $7,000 deductible, the silver plan costs $400 a month with a $4,500 deductible, and the gold plan costs $500 a month with a $1,500 deductible. The estimated annual costs are: bronze $3,600 + $3,000 = $6,600; silver $4,800 + $3,000 = $7,800; gold $6,000 + $1,500 = $7,500. Bronze is estimated cheapest here, because the care costs are below all the deductibles. If the expected care were $8,000, gold would win, because its deductible caps the care cost at $1,500.
What to do next
Check the cost-sharing reductions on silver, which this estimate does not cover, and check whether the doctors are in the network. The HMO vs PPO vs HDHP comparison can compare the plan types, and the COBRA vs ACA comparison can compare the coverage after a job loss.
When each level wins
Bronze usually wins when little care is needed, because the premium is lowest and the care costs stay below the deductible, so the total is the premium plus the care. Gold usually wins when a lot of care is needed, because the deductible is lowest and the insurer pays more, so the total is capped sooner. Silver is in the middle, and it is the only level that gets cost-sharing reductions, which cut the deductible and the copays for people with low income, so a person who qualifies for them should check silver first, because the reductions can make silver cheaper than bronze. This comparison is an estimate: it leaves out the coinsurance and the copays after the deductible, so check the plan documents for the full picture. Compare the plans on healthcare.gov during open enrollment, because the premiums and the deductibles change every year.
Common questions
What are the metal levels?
Bronze, silver, gold, and platinum: they show how the costs are split between the insurer and the person.
What does bronze pay?
About 60% of the average costs. Silver pays about 70%, and gold about 80%.
What are cost-sharing reductions?
Discounts that cut the deductible and the copays, available only on silver plans, for people with low income.
Is bronze always cheapest?
No. Bronze has the lowest premium but the highest deductible, so it suits people who need little care.
Is this a quote?
No. Take it as an estimate that leaves out the coinsurance and the copays after the deductible.