Repayment Assistance Plan (RAP) vs IBR: Which Student Loan Plan Fits in 2026

If you're on the SAVE plan and you open your loan account today, you'll find a new landscape: SAVE is gone, and the Repayment Assistance Plan — RAP — is the new income-driven option, alongside the older Income-Based Repayment plan, IBR. Most guides still list SAVE as if it were available, and that's the first thing to correct. The choice in 2026 is repayment assistance plan (RAP) vs IBR, and the two plans work differently enough that the wrong choice can cost a borrower hundreds of dollars a month.

Graduates on stage at a graduation ceremony
Photo by Виталий Уайлд, CC BY-SA 4.0

What replaced SAVE? Federal Student Aid ended the Saving on a Valuable Education plan by court order on March 10, 2026, and it is no longer available. Borrowers on SAVE must choose a different repayment plan, and the two new options Federal Student Aid points to are the Tiered Standard Plan and the Repayment Assistance Plan. IBR remains available as the older income-driven route. The sections below compare RAP and IBR on the points that decide which one fits.

What happened to SAVE

SAVE was ended by a court order, and Federal Student Aid states plainly that it is no longer available to borrowers and that borrowers must choose a different repayment plan. The months borrowers spent in SAVE forbearance do not count toward income-driven repayment forgiveness or toward Public Service Loan Forgiveness, which is a costly detail for borrowers who were counting those months.

The change also affects the other older plans. PAYE and ICR are to be retired no later than July 1, 2028, under Federal Student Aid's income-driven repayment guidance. Borrowers on PAYE or ICR should plan to move to RAP or IBR before the retirement date, rather than waiting for the deadline to arrive.

Borrowers who were on SAVE shouldn't assume their servicer has already moved them. The servicer should have communicated the options, but the borrower is responsible for choosing a plan and enrolling in it. A borrower who does nothing risks being placed on a standard plan with a much higher payment than an income-driven plan would give.

How RAP works

RAP is the new income-driven repayment plan created to replace SAVE. Its payment is based on the borrower's adjusted gross income, and it's designed to produce a payment that rises with income. Secondary reporting describes RAP as having a minimum monthly payment — reported as $10 — which means that even a borrower with very low income would pay something, rather than nothing. That figure has not been verified at studentaid.gov for this guide, and the borrower should confirm the current minimum with Federal Student Aid or their servicer before relying on it.

RAP also has provisions for borrowers with dependents and for interest: the plan is designed so that unpaid interest doesn't grow the balance in the way it could under older plans, though the exact treatment should be confirmed at studentaid.gov. The forgiveness timeline under RAP is reported to be longer than under some older plans, and the borrower should confirm the current timeline before choosing RAP on the basis of forgiveness alone.

RAP is available for the federal Direct Loans that income-driven plans cover. Borrowers with older FFEL loans may need to consolidate into a Direct Consolidation Loan before they can use RAP, and consolidation has consequences — it can reset the count toward forgiveness in some circumstances, and it changes the loan's terms. A borrower with FFEL loans should ask their servicer whether consolidation is needed and what it would cost in forgiveness progress.

How IBR works

IBR is the older income-driven plan, and it has the longest track record of the two. Its payment is based on the borrower's discretionary income — income above a threshold tied to the federal poverty level — and the payment is capped at the amount the borrower would pay under the standard 10-year plan. For a borrower with very low income, the IBR payment can be $0, which is the main difference from RAP's reported minimum payment.

IBR's forgiveness timeline is longer for newer borrowers than for older ones, and the exact period depends on when the borrower first took out federal loans. The borrower should confirm the current forgiveness period for their own situation at studentaid.gov, because the rules changed for borrowers who took out loans after July 2014, and the plan's terms are not the same for every borrower.

IBR is available to borrowers with Direct Loans and with FFEL loans, which is an advantage over RAP for borrowers who hold older FFEL loans and don't want to consolidate. A borrower who is already on IBR and is happy with the payment doesn't need to switch to RAP, and switching may not be possible in every direction — the borrower should ask their servicer whether a change from IBR to RAP, or from RAP to IBR, is allowed and what it would do to the forgiveness count.

RAP versus IBR: the comparison

The clearest difference is the payment at very low income. IBR can produce a $0 payment; RAP is reported to have a minimum payment, which means a borrower with little or no income would still pay something under RAP. For a borrower whose income is very low and who needs the lowest possible payment right now, that difference can be decisive.

The second difference is the payment formula. IBR is based on discretionary income, which takes account of family size and the federal poverty level. RAP is based on adjusted gross income, with adjustments for dependents. The two formulas can produce very different payments for the same borrower, and the only way to know which is lower is to run both numbers — the loan simulator at studentaid.gov does that, and the borrower should use it rather than guessing.

The third difference is forgiveness. Both plans lead to forgiveness after a period of qualifying payments, but the periods and the conditions differ, and the borrower's existing progress toward forgiveness may not transfer in full if they switch plans. A borrower who is close to forgiveness under IBR should be very cautious about switching to RAP, and should ask their servicer exactly how many qualifying payments would carry over.

The fourth difference is eligibility. RAP is the newer plan and covers Direct Loans; IBR covers Direct Loans and FFEL loans. A borrower with FFEL loans who doesn't want to consolidate may have no choice but IBR, while a borrower with Direct Loans can choose either.

RAP vs SAVE vs Standard vs PSLF: Which Repayment Plan Fits

The comparison on this page so far is RAP against IBR. The choice most borrowers actually face is wider than that, so here is the decision in the order that matters. First, SAVE is not an option any more — it ended on March 10, 2026, and the forbearance months that followed do not count toward forgiveness. If you are still in SAVE forbearance, every month you wait is a month that does not count, and the 90-day window to choose a new plan starts with your servicer's notice.

Second, decide whether Public Service Loan Forgiveness is your goal. If it is, you need a plan whose payments count toward PSLF: IBR and RAP both count, and so does the standard 10-year plan, though the standard plan pays the loan off in ten years and leaves little to forgive. The Tiered Standard plan does not count toward PSLF, so do not let a default placement put you on it. The PSLF guide explains the 120-payment rule and the buyback option for forbearance months.

Third, compare the payments. RAP sets the payment at 1 to 10 percent of adjusted gross income, with a $10 monthly minimum, a $50 monthly reduction for each dependent, and unpaid interest waived when you pay on time; forgiveness comes after 30 years. IBR sets the payment at 10 percent of discretionary income for borrowers who first took out federal loans after July 1, 2014, with forgiveness after 20 years, or 15 percent and 25 years for older borrowers — and IBR can produce a $0 payment at very low income, which RAP cannot. The standard 10-year plan has the highest monthly payment but the lowest total cost, because you pay less interest. There is no single best plan: the right one depends on your income, your loan balance, your family size, and whether forgiveness or a fast payoff is the goal. Run the loan simulator at studentaid.gov with your actual numbers for each plan before you choose, and re-check each year at recertification — the IDR recertification guide explains how to keep the payment right. Two eligibility rules narrow the field: RAP is the only income-driven plan available for loans disbursed on or after July 1, 2026, and IBR is the only income-driven plan that takes FFEL loans without consolidation. The repayment plans guide covers the full menu, including consolidation.

What to do if you were on SAVE

First, check the current status of the loans at studentaid.gov and with the servicer. Confirm which plan the loans are on now, what the current payment is, and how many qualifying payments have been counted toward forgiveness and toward Public Service Loan Forgiveness. Don't assume the servicer's records are correct: SAVE forbearance months don't count toward forgiveness, and the count should reflect that.

Second, run the loan simulator at studentaid.gov for both RAP and IBR, and for the Tiered Standard Plan, which is the other new plan Federal Student Aid offers. Compare the monthly payments, the total amount paid over the life of the loan, and the forgiveness date under each. The cheapest monthly payment isn't always the cheapest plan overall, because a lower payment can mean more interest and a longer repayment period.

Third, enroll in the chosen plan and set a reminder to recertify income each year. Income-driven plans require annual recertification, and missing it can raise the payment to the standard amount. Finally, keep the records: the plan selection, the recertification dates, and the payment counts. If the servicer makes an error, those records are the evidence the borrower needs to get it corrected.

The repayment assistance plan 2026 is the plan that replaced SAVE: a RAP student loan payment is set by income, with a fixed monthly amount that does not change with family size the way the older plans did. The comparison most borrowers need is IBR vs RAP — IBR is the older income-based plan that is still open, while RAP is the new default for borrowers who were on SAVE. If you were on SAVE, the practical question is not which plan is better in theory but which one keeps your payments affordable and your months counting toward forgiveness, and that is the save plan replacement choice this guide walks through.

Is student loan forgiveness taxable in 2026?

For most borrowers, the answer changed on January 1, 2026. From 2021 through 2025, the American Rescue Plan Act excluded most forgiven student loan debt from federal taxable income, so a borrower whose loans were forgiven in those years generally did not owe federal income tax on the forgiven amount. That exclusion was always temporary, it expired on December 31, 2025, and Congress did not extend it. Forgiveness that takes effect on or after January 1, 2026 is generally treated as cancellation-of-debt income again, which means the forgiven amount is added to your income for the year and taxed at your ordinary rate. The lender or servicer generally reports the forgiven amount to you and to the IRS on Form 1099-C.

That general rule has important exceptions, and which one applies depends on the program that forgave the loan. Public Service Loan Forgiveness has its own permanent exclusion in the tax code, so PSLF forgiveness remains tax-free. Teacher Loan Forgiveness also keeps its own exclusion. Forgiveness under an income-driven repayment plan, including the new Repayment Assistance Plan, does not have its own exclusion, so the balance forgiven after 20 or 25 years of payments is generally taxable in the year it is forgiven. Discharges for death or total and permanent disability are treated under a separate provision of the tax code, so confirm the current treatment in IRS guidance before you file rather than assuming it matches the general rule.

A few other points affect the bill. The tax is based on the year the debt is canceled, not the year you applied, so timing matters if your forgiveness straddles the end of 2025. If your debts exceeded your assets immediately before the cancellation, the insolvency exclusion may let you exclude some or all of the forgiven amount, claimed on IRS Form 982. State tax treatment is separate and varies: some states follow the federal rule and some do not. Before you plan around a forgiveness date, check IRS Topic No. 431 and Publication 4681, keep every notice about the discharge, and consider talking to a tax professional, because the amount at stake can be large. Our Public Service Loan Forgiveness guide explains the program that forgives the balance.

SAVE has ended: the deadline, the default, and your two choices

The Saving on a Valuable Education plan is gone. A federal court ended SAVE in March 2026, and the One Big Beautiful Bill Act ended it by statute. If you were on SAVE, you are not on a repayment plan any more — you are in an administrative forbearance while the transition runs — and those forbearance months earn no qualifying payment credit toward forgiveness or toward Public Service Loan Forgiveness.

Here is how the transition works, according to Federal Student Aid. Servicers started sending notices to SAVE borrowers on July 1, 2026, and every SAVE borrower will be notified before the end of 2026. Once you hear from your servicer, you have 90 days to choose another repayment plan you are eligible for. If you do not choose, your servicer sends a final 30-day notice, and after that you are automatically enrolled in a fixed payment plan: the Standard Repayment Plan, or the Tiered Standard Plan if you have a loan disbursed on or after July 1, 2026. You do not have to wait for the notice — you can apply for a new plan at any time on StudentAid.gov.

For most former SAVE borrowers, the choice is between Income-Based Repayment and the Repayment Assistance Plan. IBR remains open for borrowers whose loans were disbursed before July 1, 2026. RAP launched on July 1, 2026, and it is the only income-driven plan available to anyone with a loan disbursed on or after that date. Both count toward PSLF. Pay As You Earn and Income-Contingent Repayment close no later than July 1, 2028, after which IBR and RAP are the two income-driven plans left. The comparison elsewhere on this page works through the payment math; the point of this section is the clock. Every month you stay in SAVE forbearance is a month that does not count, and the 90-day window starts with your notice, not with a single national date. If buyback is part of your plan, read the PSLF buyback tracker guide before you move.

Frequently asked questions

Is the SAVE plan still available?

No. A court order ended the SAVE plan on March 10, 2026, and Federal Student Aid states it is no longer available. Borrowers on SAVE must choose a different plan, such as the Repayment Assistance Plan, IBR, or the Tiered Standard Plan.

What is the difference between RAP and IBR?

RAP is the new income-driven plan that replaced SAVE; its payment is based on adjusted gross income and it is reported to have a minimum monthly payment. IBR is the older income-driven plan; its payment is based on discretionary income and can be $0 for borrowers with very low income.

Can I switch from IBR to RAP?

It depends on your loans and your servicer's rules. Ask your servicer whether a switch is allowed and how many of your qualifying payments toward forgiveness would carry over before you switch.

Do SAVE forbearance months count toward forgiveness?

No. Federal Student Aid states that SAVE forbearance months do not count toward income-driven repayment forgiveness or Public Service Loan Forgiveness.

Which repayment plan is best if I want PSLF?

Income-Based Repayment and the Repayment Assistance Plan both count toward PSLF, and so does the standard 10-year plan, though it pays the loan off in ten years and leaves little to forgive. The Tiered Standard plan does not count toward PSLF, so do not let a default placement put you on it.

How long until my loans are forgiven on RAP vs IBR?

On the Repayment Assistance Plan, forgiveness comes after 30 years of qualifying payments. On Income-Based Repayment, it comes after 20 years for borrowers who first took out federal loans after July 1, 2014, and after 25 years for older borrowers.

Sources

  • Federal Student Aid — Saving on a Valuable Education (SAVE) Plan: a court order ended the SAVE Plan on March 10, 2026; it is no longer available to borrowers and borrowers must choose a different repayment plan; two new plans available: Tiered Standard Plan and Repayment Assistance Plan (RAP); SAVE forbearance months do not count toward IDR forgiveness or PSLF; PAYE and ICR to be retired no later than July 1, 2028.
  • Federal Student Aid — Repayment Assistance Plan: payments of 1 to 10 percent of income, a $10 minimum, a $50 monthly reduction per dependent, unpaid interest waived on on-time payments, and forgiveness after 30 years.
  • Federal Student Aid — Income-Based Repayment: 10 percent of discretionary income for newer borrowers with forgiveness after 20 years; 15 percent and 25 years for older borrowers.

Related guides

Related tools