Borrower Defense to Repayment: How to Apply and What to Expect

Graduates in caps and gowns at a commencement ceremony
Photo by DonkeyHotey, CC BY 2.0

Borrower defense to repayment is the federal process for asking the U.S. Department of Education to cancel some or all of your federal student loans because the school you attended misled you or broke the law. It is not a general forgiveness program for people who found college expensive, and it is not automatic: you have to show what the school did, how it affected your decision to enroll and borrow, and that you suffered financial harm as a result. If the school closed before you could finish, a separate program — closed school discharge — may fit better, and you can apply for both if you might qualify for either. Both applications are free, and you do not need to pay a company to file one for you.

The rules have changed repeatedly, which is why older advice about this program is often out of date. The 2022 borrower defense rules never took effect: they were blocked in court and then suspended by the One Big Beautiful Bill Act for loans first made before July 1, 2035. For loans first disbursed on or after July 1, 2020, the stricter 2019 rules apply. Because the rules depend on when your loans were first paid out, the first step in any claim is to check your own loans on StudentAid.gov — their type, their first disbursement date, and their servicer — before you rely on any deadline or standard you read elsewhere.

Who qualifies for borrower defense

You can apply if you borrowed federal Direct Loans to attend a school and you believe the school misled you or broke the law in a way that caused you financial harm. The classic examples are a school that lied about job placement rates, about its costs, about its accreditation, or about whether its credits would transfer to another school. A claim must be tied to specific conduct by the school, such as a false statement about an important fact, a promise in the enrollment agreement that was broken, or conduct that violated the law in your state. Dissatisfaction with the quality of the teaching, or a course that did not lead to the job you hoped for, is not enough on its own.

Under the 2019 rules that apply to loans first disbursed on or after July 1, 2020, you generally must show that the school made a misrepresentation knowingly or with reckless disregard for the truth, that you reasonably relied on it, and that you suffered financial harm — and you generally must file within three years of leaving the school. For loans first disbursed before July 1, 2020, earlier rules are reported to apply, with no time limit while you still owe the loans. Confirm the rule for your own loans on the current borrower defense page at StudentAid.gov before you rely on any deadline.

Borrower defense covers federal loans only. It does not cover private student loans, and it does not cover money you paid out of pocket. If you hold older Federal Family Education Loan Program (FFEL) loans, you may first need to consolidate them into a Direct Consolidation Loan. Check your loan type on StudentAid.gov before you apply, so you are claiming the right loans.

How to apply

Apply on StudentAid.gov with your FSA ID. The application asks you to list every federal loan tied to the school in your claim, with the loan type, balance, and first disbursement date, and then to explain what the school did: what you were told, when, by whom, and how it affected your decision to enroll and borrow. Evidence strengthens a claim considerably. Useful evidence includes enrollment agreements, advertisements or brochures, emails from recruiters, job placement statistics the school published, and records of what you paid. If the school has been the subject of legal action by the federal government, a state attorney general, or the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, that history is also relevant, and you can note it in your application.

Submit the application and keep a copy of everything you sent, including the confirmation. If you think you may also qualify for closed school discharge, file that application too — the two programs cover different situations, and applying for one does not block the other.

What happens while your application is pending

After you submit, the Department of Education reviews the claim and decides whether the loans tied to that program should be canceled. The Department legally has up to three years to decide a borrower defense application, although many decisions come sooner. While you wait, you can ask for a forbearance, which pauses your payments while the application is pending — ask your servicer, and confirm whether interest continues to build during the pause, because a forbearance stops the payment, not necessarily the interest.

If your claim is approved, the loans covered by the claim are discharged: you are not required to repay the remaining balance on those loans, and your eligibility for federal student aid can be reinstated if you lost it. If your claim is denied, you can ask the Department to reconsider, and you should keep making payments unless a forbearance is in place, so the loans do not fall into default while you decide your next step. Borrowers who filed a borrower defense application before June 22, 2022, may be covered by the class settlement in Sweet v. McMahon, which set court-ordered deadlines for deciding those claims — if you filed before that date, check whether the settlement applies to you.

Closed school discharge: the other route

Closed school discharge applies when your school or campus closed before you could finish your program. You generally qualify if you were enrolled when the school closed, were on an approved leave of absence when it closed, or withdrew shortly before it closed — within 120 days before closure, or 180 days for loans first disbursed on or after July 1, 2020 — and you did not complete the program. The Department can extend that window when a school closed under exceptional circumstances, such as a loss of accreditation or a state shutdown order.

Two things disqualify a closed school claim: completing the program through a teach-out plan at another school, or transferring your credits to a comparable program at a new school. Even transferring a small number of credits can matter, so if your school closed, get advice before you transfer credits anywhere — a transfer that seems harmless can close off the discharge. Some borrowers whose schools closed between November 1, 2013 and July 1, 2020, and who did not enroll at another school that takes federal aid within three years of the closure, can receive an automatic discharge without applying. If your school closed, check the closed school page on StudentAid.gov to see whether an automatic discharge applies to you.

Frequently asked questions

What is borrower defense to repayment?

It is a federal process for canceling federal Direct Loans when the school misled you or broke the law in a way that caused you financial harm, such as lying about job placement rates, costs, accreditation, or credit transfer.

Who can apply for borrower defense?

Anyone who borrowed federal Direct Loans to attend a school they believe misled them. The application is free on StudentAid.gov, and you do not need a lawyer. Private student loans are not covered.

How long does a borrower defense decision take?

The Department of Education legally has up to three years to decide an application, although many decisions come sooner. You can ask for a forbearance while you wait.

What happens while my application is pending?

Your loans stay as they are unless you request a forbearance, which pauses payments while the claim is reviewed. Confirm with your servicer whether interest continues to build during the pause.

What is the difference between borrower defense and closed school discharge?

Closed school discharge is based on the school closing before you finished; borrower defense is based on the school misleading you. If your school closed, check closed school discharge first. If you graduated, left years earlier, or the school is still open, borrower defense may fit better. You can apply for both.

Sources

Related guides

Related tools