State Comparison Tool
Working
Moving to another state changes the taxes: the income tax, the sales tax, and the property tax all differ, and the total can differ by thousands of dollars a year. This comparison compares two states from the rates entered: the income tax rate, the sales tax rate, and the property tax rate, applied to the income, the spending, and the home value entered. It does not give the rates, which the user enters from a source such as the Tax Foundation, and it doesn't cover the other costs of moving, which the moving planner can estimate. In effect, it is a State Tax calculator for two states at once: it compares the income tax, the sales tax, and the property tax from the rates entered.
What this calculator does
This comparison answers which of two states costs less in tax. You put in the income, the spending, and the home value, and the income tax rate, the sales tax rate, and the property tax rate for each state, and it works out the tax total for each and the difference. It does not give the rates.
How this is calculated
Enter the annual income, the annual spending, and the home value, which are the same for both states. Then enter the rates for state A and state B: the income tax rate, the sales tax rate, and the property tax rate, as percentages. In real terms, it works out each tax for each state: the income tax is the income times the income tax rate, the sales tax is the spending times the sales tax rate, and the property tax is the home value times the property tax rate. It adds them up and shows which state costs less and by how much. The rates should come from a source such as the Tax Foundation, because the rates change and differ by locality.
Source
Rates are entered by the user. State income tax rates are published by the Tax Foundation.
Limitations
It uses the rates entered; it doesn't give the rates, and the rates change and differ by locality. It covers only the income tax, the sales tax, and the property tax, not the other costs of living or moving. What you get is a comparison of the rates entered, not a tax calculation.
What each input means
Income, spending, home value. The annual income, the annual spending, and the home value, the same for both states. Rates A and B. The income tax rate, the sales tax rate, and the property tax rate for each state, as percentages.
How to read your result
This comparison shows the income tax, the sales tax, and the property tax for each state, the total for each, and which state costs less and by how much. Check the rates from a source such as the Tax Foundation, because they change and differ by locality.
Worked example
Take a household with income of $80,000, spending of $30,000, and a home worth $350,000. State A has rates of 5% income tax, 8% sales tax, and 1.1% property tax: the income tax is $4,000, the sales tax is $2,400, and the property tax is $3,850, for a total of $10,250. State B has rates of 0% income tax, 6% sales tax, and 1.5% property tax: the income tax is $0, the sales tax is $1,800, and the property tax is $5,250, for a total of $7,050. State B costs $3,200 less in tax, although the other costs of living may differ.
What to do next
Check the rates from a source such as the Tax Foundation, and remember that the other costs of living may differ. The moving relocation planner can estimate the cost of moving, and the property tax estimator can work out the property tax.
What to watch out for
The most common mistake with a state comparison is comparing only the income tax. For most people, a state with no income tax may have a high property tax or a high sales tax, and the total can be higher than a state with an income tax, so the comparison should include all three taxes, as this comparison does, and also the other costs, such as the housing, the insurance, and the utilities, which differ by state. The second most common mistake is using the wrong rates: the income tax rate depends on the income and the filing status, the sales tax rate depends on the city and the county, and the property tax rate depends on the school district, so the rates must be for the specific place, not a state average. Check the rates with the Tax Foundation or the state tax agency, because the rates change. In real terms, the third most common mistake is forgetting that the comparison uses the same income, spending, and home value for both states, while in reality the home value and the spending would differ, because the housing costs differ. For most people, this comparison is a guide, not a tax calculation, and the moving relocation planner on this site can estimate the cost of moving. Do not move for taxes alone: the job, the family, and the quality of life matter too.
Common questions
Which taxes does this compare?
The income tax, the sales tax, and the property tax.
Where do I get the rates?
From a source such as the Tax Foundation. The rates change and differ by locality.
Does it cover the cost of living?
No. It covers only the three taxes. The other costs may differ.
Is state B always cheaper?
No. It depends on the rates and the household’s income, spending, and home value.
Does this include local taxes?
No. The rates entered should be the combined rates, or the comparison will miss the local taxes.