BenefitBeacon

← All tools

Debt Snowball vs Avalanche Calculator

Working

There are two popular ways to pay off several debts: the snowball, which pays the smallest balance first for quick wins, and the avalanche, which pays the highest rate first to save the most interest. The avalanche always saves at least as much interest, but the snowball can keep motivation higher by clearing a debt sooner. This calculator compares the two orders on the debts you put in: it works out the interest under each order and which debt is cleared first. It doesn't make the payments, and it assumes a fixed total payment each month.

Illustration of rising bars and a coin, representing snowball vs avalanche.

What this calculator does

This calculator answers which debt payoff order is better. You put in two debts, each with a balance, a rate, and a minimum payment, plus the extra amount paid each month, and it works out the total interest and the months under the snowball order and under the avalanche order, and says which saves more interest and which clears a debt first. It also explains the trade-off between motivation and interest saved. It does not make the payments.

How this is calculated

Both methods pay the minimum on every debt and put the extra on one debt at a time. The snowball puts the extra on the smallest balance first. The avalanche puts the extra on the highest rate first. The interest is worked out month by month for each debt, at its own rate, until both are paid off. The avalanche saves at least as much interest as the snowball, because it always attacks the most expensive debt first, but the snowball clears the smallest debt sooner, which can keep the borrower motivated.

Source

Debt payoff methods are explained by the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau at consumerfinance.gov — Debt Collection.

Limitations

It covers two debts and assumes fixed rates, fixed minimum payments, and no new charges. Day to day, a real payoff has more debts, variable rates, and new charges, so the actual figures will differ. What you get is a comparison for planning, not a payoff plan.

What each input means

Debt 1 and Debt 2. Each debt has a balance, an annual rate, and a minimum monthly payment. Extra payment. The extra amount paid each month on top of the minimums, which goes to the target debt.

How to read your result

Read the interest saved first, then the months. The avalanche saves at least as much interest as the snowball, and the difference is larger when the rates differ a lot. The snowball clears the smallest debt first, which can keep motivation higher. If the rates are the same, the two methods give the same interest, and the snowball is the better choice for motivation.

Worked example

Take Debt 1 with a $2,000 balance at 22% and a $50 minimum, and Debt 2 with a $5,000 balance at 10% and a $100 minimum, with $200 extra a month. The snowball attacks Debt 1 first, because it is smaller, and clears it first. The avalanche attacks Debt 1 first too, because it has the higher rate, so the two methods agree here. Take Debt 1 with a $5,000 balance at 10% and Debt 2 with a $2,000 balance at 22%: the snowball attacks Debt 2 first and the avalanche attacks Debt 2 first as well, because it is both smaller and more expensive. The methods differ when the smallest debt isn't the most expensive one.

What to do next

Pick the method that will actually be followed: the best plan is the one that gets finished. The credit card payoff calculator can work out a single card, and the budget planner can find the extra payment.

What to watch out for

The most common mistake with debt payoff is paying only the minimum on every debt. The minimum covers mostly interest, and the balance barely falls, so the debt can take years to pay off. The snowball method pays the smallest debt first, which gives quick wins and keeps the motivation high, while the avalanche method pays the highest interest rate first, which saves the most money, and the right method is the one the borrower will stick with. The second most common mistake is not stopping new borrowing while paying off the old debts: the payoff plan only works if no new debt is added, so the credit cards should be put away. The third most common mistake is forgetting to build a small emergency fund first: without one, the next emergency goes on a credit card and the payoff starts again, so save a small buffer before paying extra on the debts. Check the interest rates on the statements, because the rates are what the avalanche method needs, and the rates can be wrong if they are guessed. Keep the plan updated, because the balances change each month, and the order can change too. The credit card payoff calculator on this site can work out the payoff for a single card.

Common questions

What is the snowball method?

Pay the minimum on every debt and put the extra on the smallest balance first, for quick wins.

What is the avalanche method?

Pay the minimum on every debt and put the extra on the highest rate first, to save the most interest.

Which saves more interest?

The avalanche, or they tie. The avalanche always saves at least as much interest.

Which is better for motivation?

Usually the snowball, because it clears a debt sooner.

What if the rates are the same?

The two methods give the same interest, so pick the snowball for the quick win.

Sources

Related guides

Official sources

Benefit rules, amounts and application steps come from the administering agency. These links open the official agency home page in a new tab. Program pages link to the agency named on the page.