Small Business Lead Generation: What Works, What It Costs, and How to Measure It

Small business lead generation is the work of finding people who may buy from your business, and turning their interest into a conversation. For a small business, it's usually the difference between a business that grows and one that waits for customers to find it. The trouble is that there are many ways to generate leads, they cost very different amounts, and the cheapest way isn't always the best way for a particular business.

A small business owner working on marketing at a laptop
Photo by Infusionsoft, CC BY-SA 2.0

How do you get more leads? You need a clear offer, a clear audience, and a way to reach that audience that you can measure. That is small business marketing in its simplest form: a clear offer, a clear audience, and a channel you can measure. Without the first two, the third won't help: a campaign that reaches the wrong people, or offers something they don't want, will produce leads that don't buy.

What a lead is, and what it is not

A lead is a person or a business that has shown interest in what you sell, and whose contact details you have, with their permission. A website visit isn't a lead. A social media like isn't a lead. A lead is someone you can follow up with, who has given you a reason to do so — they asked for a quote, downloaded a guide, booked a call, or signed up for a consultation.

Quality matters more than number. Ten leads who are ready to buy are worth more than a hundred who aren't, and a campaign that produces a hundred low-quality leads isn't a success. Judge a lead by whether it matches your customer, whether it has a real need, and whether it can pay. That's the test to apply before you spend more on the channel that produced it.

The main channels, and what they cost

The main channels are search advertising, social media advertising, search optimization, content, email, referrals, and partnerships. Search advertising puts you in front of people already looking for what you sell, and it costs per click. Social media advertising puts you in front of people who match your audience, and it costs per impression or per click. Search optimization and content take time and produce leads slowly, but the leads cost less once the content ranks. Email is cheap, but it only works with a list you've built with permission. Referrals are the cheapest leads of all, and they close at the highest rate — but they can't be bought.

Cost per lead varies by industry, by channel, and by the offer, and it's the figure to track, not the total spend. A channel that costs more per lead but produces leads that close is cheaper than a channel that costs less per lead but produces leads that don't buy. Calculate the cost per lead and the cost per customer, not just the cost per click.

Tools: what they do and what they do not do

Lead generation tools fall into a few types: tools that find contact details, tools that capture leads on a website, tools that send and track email, and tools that score leads by how likely they are to buy. That last type is lead scoring: ranking each lead by how likely it is to buy, so the follow-up goes to the best leads first. A tool can make the work faster, but it can't fix a weak offer or a wrong audience. A list of contact details bought from a broker isn't a lead list; it's a list of people who haven't asked to hear from you, and contacting them can breach privacy rules and damage your reputation.

Before you buy a tool, be clear about the job it will do: capture leads on your site, follow up by email, or find businesses to contact. One tool that does one job well is usually better than a suite that does several jobs badly. Try the free version first, and measure whether it produces leads that buy, not whether it looks impressive.

Measuring what works

Measure three things: how many leads each channel produces, how many of those leads become customers, and how much each customer costs to acquire. The conversion rate from lead to customer is the most important of the three, because it's the figure that tells you whether the leads are any good. A channel with a high conversion rate and a high cost per lead can still be the best channel, if the customers it produces are worth more.

Track the source of every lead, from the first contact to the sale, and review the figures monthly. A channel that produced good leads three months ago may have stopped working, and a channel that looked expensive may have become cheaper as you improved the offer. The review is the work; the tool only holds the numbers.

The offer: the part most small businesses skip

The offer is what the lead gets in exchange for their contact details: a quote, a consultation, a guide, a sample, a discount, or a trial. It has to be specific and valuable to the person you want to reach. A generic offer — sign up for our newsletter — produces few leads, because it promises nothing the reader wants. A specific offer — a free quote for a roof replacement, a guide to choosing a care home, a trial of a service — produces more, because it promises something concrete.

Test the offer before you spend on the channel. A small test, with a small budget, will tell you whether the offer works, and it will tell you cheaply. A large campaign built on an untested offer is the most common way small businesses waste money on lead generation.

Common mistakes

The most common mistakes are buying a list of contacts and calling it lead generation, spending on advertising before the offer is tested, judging a channel by the number of leads rather than by the number of customers, and not following up quickly. A lead followed up within an hour is far more likely to become a customer than one followed up the next day, and a lead that is never followed up is money wasted.

Another mistake is ignoring referrals. Asking a satisfied customer for a referral, and making it easy for them to give one, is the cheapest lead generation a small business has — and the one most often neglected.

Frequently asked questions

What is a lead?

A person or business that has shown interest in what you sell and whose contact details you have, with their permission. A website visit or a social media like isn't a lead.

Which lead generation channel is best?

It depends on your business, your audience, and your offer. Judge a channel by the cost per customer, not by the cost per click or the number of leads.

Should I buy a list of contacts?

No. A bought list is people who haven't asked to hear from you, and contacting them can breach privacy rules and damage your reputation.

How quickly should I follow up a lead?

As quickly as you can. A lead followed up within an hour is far more likely to become a customer than one followed up the next day.

Sources

Related guides