PAYE and ICR Closing: What Borrowers Must Do
Two income-driven repayment plans — PAYE and ICR — are closing, and if you are on one of them, you will need to switch. The Federal Student Aid IDR FAQ states that PAYE and ICR are to be retired no later than July 1, 2028. You may have seen July 1, 2027 reported as the closing date, but the Federal Student Aid IDR FAQ does not confirm that as the retirement date, so this guide uses the verified July 1, 2028 date — and advises switching well before then. Check the current rule at studentaid.gov, and ask your servicer in writing what date applies to your loans.

What PAYE and ICR are
PAYE — Pay As You Earn — sets the monthly payment at 10 percent of discretionary income and forgives the remaining balance after 20 years of qualifying payments. ICR — Income-Contingent Repayment — is an older plan that sets the payment at the lesser of 20 percent of discretionary income or what you would pay on a 12-year standard plan, with forgiveness after 25 years. Both are for federal Direct Loans, and ICR is the plan Parent PLUS borrowers can use after consolidating.
Both plans mattered to a lot of borrowers. PAYE was often the lowest-payment plan for those who qualified, because its percentage was lower than IBR's for older borrowers and its forgiveness period was shorter. ICR was the only income-driven plan available to Parent PLUS borrowers — essential for parents who borrowed for their children's education. Their closing affects a large number of borrowers, and the switch needs planning, not leaving until the last month.
The closing date: what is verified
Here is what is verified: the Federal Student Aid IDR FAQ states that PAYE and ICR are to be retired no later than July 1, 2028. July 1, 2027 was reported as the closing date, but the IDR FAQ does not confirm it as the retirement date. Secondary sources describe July 1, 2027 as a possible last date to enroll in PAYE or ICR — but that enrollment date is not stated in the IDR FAQ either, so it is not confirmed here. Do not wait until 2028 to switch: start now, check the current rule at studentaid.gov, and ask the servicer in writing what date applies to your loans.
Why the two dates differ is not clear — they may describe different things, for example the date new enrollments stop versus the date existing borrowers must leave the plan, or a statutory date versus an administrative date. Do not try to resolve that from secondary sources. The Federal Student Aid website and your servicer are the sources that matter — get the answer in writing. And note that the SAVE plan, another income-driven plan, was ended by a court order on March 10, 2026, and is no longer available.
The options after PAYE and ICR
Borrowers leaving PAYE or ICR will need to choose another plan. The options include IBR, which remains available, and the newer Repayment Assistance Plan, known as RAP, along with the Tiered Standard Plan. Each has different payment percentages, different forgiveness periods and different eligibility rules, and the best choice depends on your loans, income and family size. If you are close to forgiveness under PAYE or ICR, check carefully how the switch affects your count toward forgiveness — that is the most important consequence of the change.
Parent PLUS borrowers face a particular problem: ICR was the only income-driven plan they could use. After ICR closes, Parent PLUS borrowers who have consolidated will need to check which plan, if any, is available to them. Ask the servicer and check the Federal Student Aid website for the current rule for Parent PLUS loans. Do not assume RAP or IBR will be available for a Parent PLUS consolidation loan without checking.
Steps to switch plans
Start by checking your current plan, your loan types and your forgiveness count at the Federal Student Aid website. Then use the loan simulator on that site to compare the plans available to you, looking at the monthly payment and the total amount paid over the life of the loan — not only the monthly payment. The simulator is free; run it for each plan that is available to you.
Once you have chosen a plan, apply through the servicer or through the Federal Student Aid website. The application asks for income information, so have proof of income ready. Keep a copy of the application and note the date you submitted it. Also ask the servicer to confirm in writing that the switch has been made, what the new payment is, and how many qualifying payments have been counted toward forgiveness. That confirmation is your record if there is a dispute later.
PAYE closing and ICR closing are the same event for borrowers: both income-driven plans stop taking new enrollments, and the PAYE ICR retirement means existing borrowers need a new plan before the deadline. The practical step is to switch repayment plan early — compare the replacement income-driven plan on payment size and forgiveness count, ask the servicer to confirm the switch in writing, and keep a copy, because a payment made under a plan that does not qualify will not count toward forgiveness.
Common mistakes
The most common mistake is waiting until the closing date to switch. The switch takes time, and a borrower who waits may miss the deadline and be moved to a standard plan with a much higher payment. Switch well before the July 1, 2028 retirement date — do not wait until 2028 to start. A second mistake is choosing a plan based only on the monthly payment: a plan with a lower monthly payment may cost more in total, because the repayment period is longer and more interest accrues.
Another mistake is not checking the forgiveness count. If you are close to forgiveness under PAYE or ICR, ask the servicer how many qualifying payments have been counted and whether the count carries over to the new plan — and get that answer in writing before switching. Be careful, too, about companies that charge a fee to switch plans: switching is free through the servicer, and a company offering to switch plans for a fee is not providing a service you cannot get for free.
Frequently asked questions
Are PAYE and ICR closing?
Yes. Both plans are being retired no later than July 1, 2028, according to the Federal Student Aid IDR FAQ, and borrowers on them must switch to another plan before then. July 1, 2027 was reported as the closing date, but that date is not confirmed by the Federal Student Aid IDR FAQ as the retirement date. Check the current date at studentaid.gov and switch well before July 1, 2028.
What plans can I switch to?
The options include IBR and the newer Repayment Assistance Plan (RAP), along with the Tiered Standard Plan. Which plans are available depends on your loan types. Use the loan simulator at studentaid.gov to compare them.
What happens to my forgiveness count if I switch?
It depends on the plan and on the current rules. Ask your servicer how many qualifying payments have been counted and whether the count carries over, and get the answer in writing.
Is SAVE still an option?
No. SAVE was ended by a court order on March 10, 2026, and is no longer available. Borrowers on SAVE must choose a different plan.
Sources
- Federal Student Aid, U.S. Department of Education — SAVE plan ended by court order March 10, 2026; PAYE and ICR to be retired no later than July 1, 2028 (FSA IDR FAQ); two new plans: Tiered Standard Plan and Repayment Assistance Plan (RAP).
Related guides
- Student Loan Repayment Plans: Which One Fits Your Loans
- IBR Partial Financial Hardship Rule Removed in July 2025
- Student Loan $0 Payment While Unemployed via IDR
- Childcare for College Students: Help for Student Parents
- Federal Student Loans: Direct Loans, Limits, Interest Rates
- Graduate Loan Gap: When Federal Loans Fall Short