How Much Is a Silver Dollar Worth? Melt & Key Dates

A common circulated Morgan or Peace silver dollar is worth about $36 in silver. Each one holds 0.7734 troy ounces of silver, and at a spot price of $47 an ounce — the Kitco quote on November 16, 2026 — that metal is worth $36.35. Most dealers pay a little over melt for common dates in average shape, so $36 to $40 is a realistic expectation for an ordinary circulated coin.

That is the floor, not the ceiling. A few dates are rare enough to be worth hundreds or thousands, and uncirculated coins carry a premium over worn ones. The year, the mint mark, and the condition decide which side of that gap your coin sits on.

Stacks of silver coins on a plain background
Photo: Katherine Ridgley via Flickr, CC BY 2.0

Silver dollar melt value

Morgan dollars (1878–1904, and 1921) and Peace dollars (1921–1935) are 90 percent silver and 10 percent copper. Each weighs 26.73 grams and holds 0.7734 troy ounces of pure silver. The melt value is that weight times the current spot price:

0.7734 × $47 = $36.35. That is the metal value on November 16, 2026. The spot price moves every day — silver has traded between roughly $47 and $121 an ounce in 2026 — so the melt value moves with it. To work out today's figure, multiply 0.7734 by the current spot price. Dealers usually buy common circulated dollars at or slightly above melt, and sell them a few dollars higher.

The melt value is a floor for common dates, not a price guide. A coin is never worth less than its silver content to a buyer who wants the metal, but a rare date or a coin in superb condition is worth far more than melt, and the metal price is irrelevant to that premium.

Morgan vs Peace dollars

CoinYearsSilverCommon circulated value
Morgan dollar1878–1904, 19210.7734 ozNear melt, about $36–$40
Peace dollar1921–19350.7734 ozNear melt, about $36–$40
Eisenhower dollar (clad)1971–1978NoneFace value, $1
Eisenhower dollar (40% silver)1971–19760.3161 ozAbout $15 in silver
American Silver Eagle1986–present1 oz (.999 fine)Spot price plus a premium

Morgan and Peace dollars are worth the same as metal. The difference between them is collector demand: Morgans are the more collected series, so high-grade Morgans carry bigger premiums, but for a worn coin pulled from a drawer, the two are interchangeable.

Eisenhower dollars are the trap. The ordinary ones from circulation are copper-nickel clad and worth exactly one dollar. Only the collector versions sold in mint sets — marked with an S mint mark and sold at a premium when new — contain 40 percent silver, worth about $15 in metal at a $47 spot price.

Key dates worth far more than melt

A handful of dates were struck in small numbers or survive in small numbers, and those are the coins that make headlines. For Morgan dollars the famous rarities are the 1893-S, the 1889-CC, and the 1895 — the 1895 was struck only as a proof, so a circulation-strike 1895 does not exist and any apparent one needs expert checking. For Peace dollars the keys are the 1928 and the 1934-S.

Key dates in worn condition still sell for hundreds of dollars, and in high grades they reach five or six figures. But rarity is specific: an 1893 from Philadelphia is not an 1893-S, and the mint mark — the small letter under the eagle on the back of a Morgan, or above the eagle's tail on a Peace dollar — is what makes the difference. A coin with no mint mark was struck in Philadelphia.

If your coin matches a key date, do not sell it to the first buyer. Get it authenticated and graded by a major service such as PCGS or NGC. Counterfeits of the famous dates exist, and grading is what turns a rare coin into a saleable one.

How condition changes the value

Coin dealers grade on a 70-point scale, and the price jumps sharply at the top. A heavily worn Morgan is a melt coin. The same date in uncirculated condition — no wear, original mint shine — can be worth several times melt. The difference between two adjacent high grades can be hundreds of dollars, which is why grading exists.

Two rules protect your coin's value. Never clean it. Cleaning leaves hairline scratches and strips the natural surface, and a cleaned coin sells for less than a dirty original. And hold it by the edge, not the face: fingerprints on silver etch into the surface over time.

How to check your silver dollar

  1. Check the date and mint mark. Morgans and Peace dollars (1878–1935) are silver. Eisenhower dollars are usually not.
  2. Look at the edge. A silver dollar's edge is solid silver-gray. A clad coin shows a copper stripe.
  3. Weigh it if you can. A Morgan or Peace dollar weighs 26.73 grams. A clad Eisenhower dollar weighs 22.68 grams.
  4. Work out the melt value. Multiply 0.7734 by today's spot price. That is your floor.
  5. Compare the date against the key-date list. If it matches, get a professional opinion before selling.
  6. Get competing offers. Coin shops, shows and reputable online dealers all buy silver dollars. Two or three quotes tell you whether the first was fair.

Frequently asked questions

How much is a silver dollar worth today?

A common circulated Morgan or Peace dollar holds about $36 in silver at a $47 spot price (0.7734 troy ounces). Most sell for $36 to $40. Rare dates and uncirculated coins are worth far more.

Are all old silver dollars worth the same?

No. As metal they are identical, but collector value depends on the date, mint mark and condition. A common 1921 Morgan is a melt coin; an 1893-S is worth thousands even worn.

Is a 1971 Eisenhower dollar silver?

Usually not. Circulation Eisenhower dollars are copper-nickel clad and worth $1. Only the 40% silver collector versions, sold in mint sets with an S mint mark, contain silver — about $15 worth at a $47 spot price.

Should I clean my silver dollar before selling?

No. Cleaning scratches the surface and lowers the value. Dealers and graders pay more for an original, untouched coin than for a cleaned one, even if the cleaned one looks brighter.

Where can I sell a silver dollar?

Local coin shops, coin shows, and established online bullion and coin dealers all buy them. For a key date, have the coin graded first — a certified coin sells for more and sells faster.

Sources

Related guides

Related tools