Expungement Eligibility: Clean Slate Record Clearing

A criminal record can follow a person for years, affecting jobs, housing, education and licenses, long after the sentence has been served. Expungement is the legal process that seals or erases a criminal record, so it doesn't show up in most background checks. Clean Slate laws go further: in the states that have them, eligible records are sealed automatically, without the person having to apply. Whether either route is open to you depends on the state, the offense, and how much time has passed. Expungement eligibility depends on the offense, how long ago it was, and the state where the record sits.

Historic county courthouse complex, for a guide to expungement eligibility and clean slate laws

So can you clear your record? It depends on your state. Some states allow expungement for many offenses after a waiting period; others allow it only for a narrow set of offenses; and a few allow almost no expungement at all. This guide explains the two routes, who qualifies, and how to start.

What expungement does

Expungement, or sealing, takes a criminal record out of public view. Once a record is expunged, it generally doesn't appear in a background check by an employer, a landlord or a licensing body, and the person can legally say they weren't convicted of the offense in most circumstances. The record isn't destroyed in every state — in some states it's sealed and kept by the court and law enforcement, and it can still be seen by the police, the courts and some government agencies.

Expungement isn't a pardon, and it isn't available for every offense. A pardon forgives the offense; expungement removes the record of it. Some offenses, usually the most serious, can't be expunged in any state, and the list of offenses that can be expunged differs by state. Federal records are a separate matter: there's generally no federal expungement process for a federal conviction.

Clean Slate laws

Clean Slate laws seal eligible criminal records automatically, without the person having to file a petition or pay a fee. The state picks out the records that qualify — usually lower-level offenses where a set period has passed without a new conviction — and seals them. More states have adopted Clean Slate laws over time, but the laws differ: the offenses covered, the waiting period, and whether the person must have paid all fines and fees all vary by state.

Automatic sealing doesn't cover every record. A record that doesn't qualify for automatic sealing may still be eligible for expungement by petition, and the person has to apply for it. If you live in a Clean Slate state, check whether your record has already been sealed automatically before assuming it hasn't — and if it hasn't, check whether a petition is the route.

Who qualifies

Eligibility turns on the state, the offense, and the time since the case ended. Most states require a waiting period after the sentence, probation or parole is complete, and the period runs longer for more serious offenses. Most states require that the person hasn't been convicted of a new offense during the waiting period, and that all fines, fees and restitution have been paid. Some states exclude a person with multiple convictions, or with a conviction for an offense on the excluded list.

Juvenile records, arrests that didn't lead to a conviction, and cases that were dismissed are often easier to clear than adult convictions, and in many states they can be sealed sooner or automatically. Check the rules for the type of record you have, not only the general expungement rules.

How to apply for expungement

In a state that requires a petition, the process starts with the court where the case was heard. The person files a petition for expungement, pays a filing fee — although a fee waiver is available in many states for people who can't afford it — and the court reviews the case, sometimes at a hearing. The prosecutor can object, and the judge decides whether the record should be sealed. The process can take months, and the outcome isn't guaranteed.

Free help is available in many places. Legal aid organizations, law school clinics and expungement clinics help people check eligibility and file petitions for free. A clinic can tell you whether your record qualifies, what the waiting period is, and what documents are needed, before you pay a filing fee or hire a lawyer.

After the record is cleared

Once a record is expunged or sealed, you can apply for jobs, housing and licenses without the record appearing in most background checks. There are exceptions: some government jobs, some licenses, and immigration proceedings can still require disclosure, and the record can still be seen by law enforcement. Read the order that seals the record, and understand what it covers and what it doesn't, before answering a question about the record on an application.

If a background check still shows the record after it's been sealed, dispute it with the background check company and with the court. Background check companies are required to use current information, and a sealed record that still appears is an error that should be corrected. Keep the court order, because it's the proof that the record was sealed.

Common mistakes

The most common mistake is assuming a record is cleared when it isn't — because the state has no automatic sealing, or because the record doesn't qualify. A second is not paying the fines and fees, which can block eligibility. A third is filing in the wrong court or with the wrong form. A fourth is paying a company a large fee to file a petition that a free clinic would have filed. A fifth is answering a question about a criminal record incorrectly after it's been sealed, without understanding the exceptions.

The practical question is how to seal criminal record entries so they stop appearing on background checks — in other words, how to expunge record entries where your state allows it. Expungement usually means filing a petition and meeting a waiting period, while clean slate laws seal eligible records automatically, without a petition. Either way, the result is the same kind of relief: the record is sealed or erased for most purposes, even though it may still be visible to some government agencies.

Expunged records and immigration: what still counts

The section above notes that immigration proceedings can still require disclosure after a record is cleared. The reason is that immigration law uses its own federal definition of conviction, and it is wider than most state definitions. Under INA section 101(a)(48)(A), a conviction includes a formal judgment of guilt — and also a case where adjudication was withheld, if the person pleaded guilty or no contest, or a judge or jury found guilt, or the person admitted enough facts to warrant a finding of guilt, and the judge ordered some form of punishment, penalty, or restraint on liberty, such as probation, a fine, classes, or community service. Deferred adjudication and withheld adjudication usually still count as convictions for immigration purposes.

Two Board of Immigration Appeals decisions draw the line. In Matter of Roldan (1999), the Board held that a state action expunging, dismissing, canceling, or vacating a guilty plea or conviction under a state rehabilitative statute has no effect for immigration purposes — the person remains convicted. In Matter of Pickering (2003), the Board held the opposite for a conviction vacated because of a procedural or substantive defect in the underlying criminal proceeding, such as a failure to advise of the immigration consequences: that is not a conviction for immigration purposes. A vacatur granted only to avoid immigration consequences, or only for rehabilitation, still counts.

The disclosure duty is separate from whether the offense counts. Form N-400, and Form I-485, ask about every arrest, citation, charge, and detention — including matters that were dismissed, sealed, or expunged — and the N-400 instructions say to report all offenses, including ones expunged or pardoned. Failing to disclose can itself be a basis for denial, for fraud or misrepresentation, even when the offense itself would not have blocked the application. FBI fingerprint checks usually surface expunged records anyway. This is general information, not legal advice: how a state record-clearing order interacts with federal immigration law is fact-specific, so get advice from an immigration attorney before answering questions on an immigration application.

Frequently asked questions

What is expungement?

Expungement is the legal process that seals or erases a criminal record, so it doesn't appear in most background checks. The rules and the offenses covered are set by the state.

What is a Clean Slate law?

A law that seals eligible criminal records automatically, without the person having to apply. The offenses covered and the waiting period vary by state.

Can any criminal record be expunged?

No. Some offenses can't be expunged in any state, and the list differs by state. Federal convictions generally can't be expunged.

How do I apply for expungement?

By filing a petition with the court where the case was heard, in states that require a petition. Free help is available from legal aid organizations and expungement clinics.

Sources

Related guides